Tag Archives: excellent

I Have Some Questions for You: So great.

In 2019 I told you that Rebecca Makkai’s The Great Believers was the one book you should read that year (still true), and while I’m not yet prepared to say I Have Some Questions for You is the best thing you’ll read this year, it’s certainly in the running.

Following Brodie Kane, a podcast producer, as she returns to her high school boarding school to both teach a class and investigate the murder of her former school roommate, the book has the distinct feel of a true crime podcast (I’m sure someone has done a comparison to Serial. And… they have), but one that artfully and consciously plays with the ‘just asking questions’ element of exploring a closed murder case, the retrieval of lost memories, the unearthing of new evidence, the exploration of how changes mores of sex and race influence how crimes are investigated and prosecuted, the risks to the families of victims, the exploitation of trauma, and on.

And while all of that makes for great reading – and the murder mystery element itself is captivating – it’s the sections peppered throughout about the all too frequent ways violence against women is normalized, make routine, made mundane and forgettable that utterly gut punches.

The careful way Makkai has Brodie explore the pendulum of #metoo stories through an accusation made against Brodie’s ex-husband is nuanced and challenging not simply in how Brodie reacts, but in how Brodie reacts to the reactions, how so much of what gets told – and believed – is in the interpretation.

And that, I guess, is the heart of the book. How an innocent person can spend years in prison for a crime they obviously didn’t commit because of a story that gets told and believed. How narratives we tell ourselves about our teenage lives get made real and real and real, until we meet that story retold through another perspective as an adult and are forced to consider whether we might have believed a fiction. How everyone we know and everything with think is necessarily a story and that the real failure – of individuals and institutions – is in not recognizing the way this story is made, made up, and reified.

It’s really good.

Leave a comment

Filed under American literature, Fiction, New York Times Notable, Prize Winner

Far to Go: Literary blindspots

I joined a book club for the friends, but the real value of the club has been the introduction of new authors and titles that I’d not have found myself (Okay, bit of a stretch, the friendship (and wine) has been pretty valuable, too….). Don’t despair if you’re not the book club kind of person, you can get the same direction to new kinds of reads from your librarian, your independent bookseller, or *cough* your favourite book review blogger.

That said you probably don’t need me to introduce you to Alison Pick. Because (unlike me) you probably know about her: Far to Go was nominated for the Man Booker, she’s won a bazillion important prizes, been on all of the lists of best books, identified as “the” up-and-coming Canadian author. Oh and she’s an alumnus of the University of Guelph. So… I had a little literary blindspot. Tiny.  So thanks book club friends for getting me sorted. Now that I’ve found her writing I’ll not be forgetting it (or stopping at this novel). All this to say Far to Go is excellent and you should read it, too. If you’ve not met Pick’s writing yet either, let this be the moment of unexpected pleasure. If you’re already familiar then I have to know: Why didn’t you tell me sooner? (An aside – why aren’t all of you sending me recommendations all the time? I could stand to have more variety pointed my way… Anyway.)

So the book. Set in Czechoslovakia in 1939 it follows the story of Marta, a governess for a rich, secular Jewish Bauer family as the Nazis seize control of the country. Woven throughout are short passages of the narrative of a contemporary researcher in Canada who researches the lives of the Kindertransport: Jewish children ferried out of occupied countries at the outbreak of war.

These short contemporary flashes make explicit the constructedness of the imagined life of the past, the sort of hiccuping self-awareness of historical fiction’s reminder to readers that we know history through fragments, and we create a pieced together narrative from these fragments, filling in gaps with fictions so that we can have the assurance of plot. Serving more than the usual ritual of historiographic metafiction, the attention to the holes of history work here as a thematic expression of the loss of life and attendant story that the Holocaust represents: the absence in the present that can only ever be filled by imagination.

The bulk of the narrative is given over to Marta and her commitment to the Bauer family (a parallel to the way the contemporary narrator is similarly invested in the families she chronicles in her research), with questions of how Marta defines her worth independent of this family. Marta’s actions and motivations are rich, complex and entirely fascinating. The Bauer parents – Pavel and Annelise – are somewhat less fully developed, but are nevertheless compelling. Marta’s young charge, Pepik, is a brilliantly captured five year old. The novel rarely leaves the household – either literally or figuratively – yet it doesn’t feel claustrophobic; rather it reveals the way the grand historical moment is experienced in the small, domestic.  Taken together the family and their impossible choices that they must nevertheless make what could feel sweeping feel heartbreakingly particular.

The writing is extraordinary. I often complain about writing that is trying to be literary and so comes across as overly workshopped (I’m still trying to figure out how to best describe this writing – all I have right now is ‘knowing it when I see it.’) Far to Go is a beautiful example of not this effort-ful beauty. It is just. beautiful.

 

Leave a comment

Filed under Bestseller, Book Club, Canadian Literature, Fiction, Historical Fiction, Prize Winner