Tag Archives: Mystery

The God of the Woods: Perfect travel companion

While Long Bright River was uneven, Liz Moore’s The God of the Woods is a consistently good read. I can’t say much about the plot without getting into spoilers, but the general thrust is a young girl goes missing at an overnight camp in the 1970s. What follows is an investigation both into her disappearance and that of her younger brother, Bear, who vanished – presumed dead – 15 odd years earlier.

Weaving togethers themes of domestic and gendered violence, of class privilege, of the gap between what appears and what is, and above all of what it means to be “self-reliant” there are moments where these themes read as overdetermined and overly forceful (like the house of the wealthy family is explicitly named Self-Reliance). Though the heavy-handedness sometimes struck me as… heavy handed, at other moments I didn’t mind foregoing the interpretative work and just letting the book tell me what I needed to know and find important.

This directed-ness lends to an utter absorption in the story. With choppy (not in a bad way) chapters that jump in time and perspective, the plot propels while still giving (some) space for (modest) character development. Having just finished hosting a murder mystery, I also appreciated a way played red herring and the tidiness of the ultimate outcome.

It is the kind of book you would love to have with you on a vacation, or airplane, or other occasion where you want to be absorbed and taken out of your physical place. It is not great literature (the writing is good enough to not be distracting and to be occasionally striking, but is not on the whole beautiful; the characters are good enough to be believable and engrossing, but not on the whole complex) but it is good and extremely enjoyable in the way it reminds you that you, yes you, can read for hours at a time and forget where you are and where you need to be until your body reminds you. So put your cellphone somewhere the notifications can’t reach you and sink in.

1 Comment

Filed under Fiction, Mystery

Long Dark River

Liz Moore’s Long Dark River starts out with such promise. It opens with a captivating premise and mystery. Two sisters (Mickey and Kasey) – one a police officer and one an opioid addict working and living the same streets. Kasey goes missing, there is a serial killer on the loose, and Mickey tries to find Kasey to keep her safe (or at least that’s what we think at the start).

And this plot carries us for the first half of the book and it is wrenching to hold the two parallel lives at once in our minds (what when wrong? how did the sisters end up estranged?). At some points Mickey forces the question of what did Kasey do wrong to end up living the life she is living and not the moral one that Mickey does – and I find this point irritating, for nothing about addiction suggests choice and in the framing of the question there is (at least at first) the idea that there is some kind of moral failing on Kasey’s part. Later in the book this question is – really far too patly and again with some kind of pinning of individual blame – explained in that their mother was in the throws of her own addiction when she was pregnant with Kasey, and so Kasey was born addicted herself. The whole thing makes it as though opioid addiction is an individual failing made by individual choice. And if there’s one thing we took from the utterly brilliant Demon Copperhead it is that this mess is not the fault of the individual user.

I digress. So halfway through when some of the questions about Kasey are resolved, the book turns – instead of to a conclusion that might be complex and nuanced about the sisters and their relationship (which is, I think, what the book is best about) to instead solving the murder mystery element. Like we care who the serial killer is? I guess we’re supposed to care who the serial killer is. And so we have to work our way through the plot structure of a Law and Order episode to chase some red herrings and eventually find the killer. It was all just so bizarrely beside the point to (what this reader saw as) the heart of the story: the relationship between Kasey and Mickey.

So I’m not sure I’d recommend it. I mean I did recommend it to a bunch of people (sorry M.) when I first started reading it because I was so taken with the family dynamic and some of the writing is Not Bad. But by the end I was sort of embarrassed to have suggested it because it becomes some other kind of book. Maybe if you go into it expecting that turn you’ll enjoy it the whole way through. You let me know.

Leave a comment

Filed under Bestseller, Fiction, Mystery

All the Sinners Bleed: Ah, now this is a mystery

S.A. Cosby’s All the Sinners Bleed was a refreshing reminder that mysteries do not have to be badly written, predictable garbage (see my very recent experience reading Ruth Ware) and can, instead, hold rich writing, subtle characters and engaging plot.

Following the first black sheriff in Charon county (some southern town that is as much a character in the book as any of the people) (as an aside – how bananas is it that police officers are elected) as he investigates a serial killer, the book cares in equal measure for the thriller plot points that kept this reader up late as it does about the social context where seven black children could go missing with their disappearances uninvestigated for years. With some side plots about white supremacists protecting statues of confederate leaders and other threads following the aggressions that fill his day the reader sees the complexity and injustice Titus has to sit in or respond to just to do his job.

*spoiler: I appeciated, too, that the serial killer was not – as I spent most of the book assuming – a character we’d spent time with as readers, so it wasn’t a whodunnit so much as a thriller-mystery focused on Titus and how he finds the killer.

And some exceptional descriptions of dinner.

Leave a comment

Filed under American literature, Fiction, Mystery, New York Times Notable, Prize Winner

Promise Falls Trilogy: That’s where I’ve been for three months

For those of you keeping track, it’s been awhile since I posted. And that’s because I let myself read Linwood Barclay’s Promise Falls trilogy (Broken Promise, Far From True, The Twenty-Three). Guys. None of them are that good. (If you were I. you’d launch into a thing about how great Tana French is and how she’s the only mystery writer you should read, but I like to give new mysteries a ride).

Why then, why did I persist? Inertia? Guilt because I’d taken all three from the ‘take a book leave a book’ shelf at the local coffee shop and the barrista had given me the side eye for taking three books and leaving none? Deep moral failing? I don’t know. But I did.

They’re just not all that captivating, the detective isn’t endearing, the mysteries themselves don’t feel like there’s too much at stake (even when the town’s water supply is poisoned you’re sort of like shrug).

So… skip, pass, move on. And deep apologies for wasting so much of my own time. Like it was so bad I just read My Name is Lucy Barton and only realized in the last twenty pages that I’d already read it. Like I needed some kind of palate cleanse… Anyway.

Leave a comment

Filed under Book I'll Forget I Read, Mystery